Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr. Dereck Mush, MD, MBA's avatar

Direct and necessary critique Sergei. Where are you seeing the healthiest dose of realism in early-stage health AI right now?

sugar2cell's avatar

This is a thoughtful and necessary reflection on responsibility in the age of AI. I appreciate the emphasis on keeping AI under human authority, maintaining clinical judgment, and protecting patient dignity.

But I think there is a critical layer missing.

We can formulate a thousand new oaths for medicine —

yet if the healthcare system itself is primarily optimized for economic throughput, efficiency, and scalability, it will inevitably produce exactly that.

AI will not correct this. It will amplify it.

The question is therefore not only how clinicians should use AI, but:

What is the system actually designed to optimize?

Because as long as the underlying incentives are misaligned with biological reality, no ethical framework alone will be sufficient to produce health.

It will produce output — not necessarily care.

10 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?